Feasibility Methodology

    Operating Expense Rationalization: The Discipline That Separates a Financeable Projection From a Rejected One

    By David Jones, MAI, CCIM

    The subtlest and most common reason a feasibility study fails lender review is not an aggressive revenue line but an understated expense structure. This is the methodology a premier analyst uses to build an expense side a credit committee can rely on.


    The attention in a feasibility study naturally falls on revenue, because revenue is where optimism is most visible and most contested. But the more common and more insidious failure sits on the other side of the pro forma. Understated operating expenses inflate net operating income just as surely as overstated revenue does, and they do so quietly, because an expense structure that runs a few points below where it should is far harder to spot than a revenue projection that reaches for a number the market will not support. This is where feasibility studies most often fail lender and SBA review, and it is where the discipline of a premier analyst is most clearly demonstrated. This piece sets out the methodology of expense rationalization, the practice of building and defending each expense line against evidence rather than deriving it from a borrower's optimism or a convenient percentage.

    The work is prepared under USPAP discipline and aligned with SBA SOP 50 10 8, which directs underwriters to evaluate against conservative assumptions and to reject studies built on unrealistic expense structures. What follows is how a rigorous analyst meets that standard.

    Why expense modeling is where studies fail

    The failure is arithmetic before it is anything else. Net operating income is revenue less operating expenses, and debt-service coverage is net operating income divided by debt service, so an error in the expense ratio flows directly and disproportionately into the coverage the lender relies on. A study that models expenses at 55 percent of revenue when the true figure is 62 percent does not overstate net operating income by 7 percent; it overstates it by the full margin those seven points represent, which on a thin-coverage deal can be the difference between a coverage ratio that clears the lender's floor and one that does not. A modest expense understatement, in other words, compounds into a material coverage overstatement, and coverage is the number on which the credit turns.

    The asymmetry with revenue is what makes expense understatement so common. A reviewer scrutinizes revenue instinctively, testing the occupancy, the rate, the volume against the market. Expenses invite less suspicion, because a plausible-looking set of line items rarely announces what it has left out, and the omissions, a missing management fee, a replacement reserve that was never funded, a property-tax line still carrying the seller's basis, are invisible unless the reviewer knows to look for them. The result is that the expense side is where an optimistic pro forma most often conceals its optimism, and where a disciplined analysis most often earns its credibility.

    The principle of expense rationalization

    Expense rationalization is the practice of justifying every line independently, from the bottom up, against industry data and market cost rather than as a percentage plug or a figure carried over from the borrower's own projection. Its method has two movements. The first is construction: each expense line is built from the operation's actual requirements, the staffing the asset needs at market wages, the utilities its consumption implies, the taxes its post-transaction assessment will produce, and benchmarked against comparable operations. The second is reconciliation: the assembled expense structure is checked against the industry's benchmark ratios as a cross-check, so that a total expense ratio far below the norm for the asset class is caught and explained rather than accepted. A line built from the bottom up and reconciled to a benchmark from the top down is a line an analyst can defend; a percentage borrowed from an optimistic projection is not.

    The major expense categories and how each is modeled

    A rationalized expense structure is built category by category, each against its own evidence. The following sets out the major lines and the benchmark discipline each requires.

    Labor and payroll. Labor is the largest or among the largest lines in most operating businesses, and it is modeled from a staffing plan at market-rate wages, with payroll taxes and benefits layered on, benchmarked against the staffing norms for the asset class. The critical adjustment is the owner's labor, addressed below, because an owner-operator who works without a market salary understates the true cost of running the business.

    Management fee. A rationalized study includes a market-rate management fee even when the business is owner-operated, commonly in the range of 3 to 6 percent of revenue depending on the asset class, roughly 5 percent for hotels, senior housing, and self-storage among others, because the lender models the business as it would operate under professional management rather than assuming the owner's uncompensated effort. Omitting the management fee is among the most frequent and most consequential expense understatements.

    Utilities. For utility-intensive assets, utilities are a major line modeled from consumption rather than a percentage, a car wash's water and sewer, a laundromat's water and gas, a data center's power, a hotel's or care facility's energy, each estimated per unit, room, or square foot against benchmark consumption. A stale or percentage-based utility assumption on a utility-heavy asset is a serious modeling failure.

    Property taxes. Property taxes are a classic point of understatement, because an acquisition or a new construction is reassessed, and a study that carries the seller's old tax basis rather than the reassessed post-transaction basis understates the line, sometimes substantially. The rationalized approach estimates taxes from the new assessed value and the local millage, reflecting the reassessment the transaction itself triggers.

    Insurance. Insurance is modeled from current market cost, not a stale figure, and the discipline matters more than it once did, because insurance costs have risen sharply in hospitality, senior care, and catastrophe-exposed markets. A property in a hail, wind, or flood-exposed region carries deductibles and premiums that a dated assumption will miss entirely.

    Repairs, maintenance, and a replacement reserve. A rationalized study funds a replacement reserve for capital items, the hotel FF&E reserve commonly modeled near 4 percent of revenue, the equipment replacement for a car wash or laundromat, the roof and HVAC for any building, which an optimistic pro forma omits entirely. The reserve is not a discretionary line; it is the recognition that capital assets wear out, and its omission flatters near-term coverage at the expense of realism.

    Other lines. Marketing and advertising, general and administrative costs, supplies, credit-card and processing fees, professional fees, and, for franchised businesses, the franchise royalty and marketing fees stated as a percentage of revenue in the franchise disclosure, are each modeled against their benchmark. Where the model reduces revenue for vacancy, credit loss, or bad debt, that offset functions like an expense and is held to the same discipline.

    Expense lineHow a rationalized study models itCommon understatement
    Labor and payrollStaffing plan at market wages, taxes and benefitsUnpaid owner or family labor
    Management feeMarket rate, ~3 to 6 percent of revenue, even if owner-operatedOmitted entirely
    UtilitiesConsumption-based, per unit, room, or square footPercentage plug on a utility-heavy asset
    Property taxesReassessed post-transaction value at local millageSeller's old tax basis
    InsuranceCurrent market cost, region-specificStale premium, missing catastrophe exposure
    Replacement reserveFunded reserve, e.g., FF&E near 4 percent of revenueOmitted entirely
    Franchise feesRoyalty and marketing per the disclosureUnderstated or excluded

    The owner-operator normalization problem

    The single most important expense insight in acquisition underwriting is that owner-operated financials systematically understate the true cost of running the business, and a rigorous analyst normalizes for it. The owner works without a market salary, so the labor line is understated by the value of that effort. Family labor is often unpaid. Personal expenses are commingled with business expenses, distorting both directions. Maintenance is frequently deferred, so the historical repair line understates the true requirement. And the seller's tax basis understates the property taxes the buyer will actually pay after reassessment. A feasibility analyst must correct all of these to model the business as a new owner, possibly relying on hired management, would actually operate it, adding back a market management fee or owner salary, removing personal and one-time items, funding the deferred maintenance and the reserve, and reassessing the taxes. This normalization is the core of SBA acquisition underwriting on the expense side, and it is precisely the work that separates a study modeling the business as it truly operates from one accepting the seller's flattering presentation.

    Benchmarking sources and expense ratios by asset class

    Rationalization depends on credible benchmarks, and a premier analysis names its sources. The recognized references include the IREM Income and Expense analyses, the RMA Annual Statement Studies, STR and CBRE trend data for hotels, NIC for senior housing, the Self Storage Association, the Coin Laundry Association, franchise disclosure Item 19 for franchised businesses, and comparable trade and market data. Against these, representative operating expense ratios and net operating income margins by asset class serve as the reconciliation anchors, hotels, senior housing, self-storage, car washes, RV parks, restaurants, and multifamily each carrying a characteristic range. The specific figures should be drawn from current editions of these sources for the market and asset in question, but the discipline is constant: a modeled expense structure is reconciled to the benchmark for its class, and a total that falls outside the range is explained or corrected rather than accepted.

    How expense modeling connects to DSCR and sensitivity

    The rationalized expense structure is what makes a coverage conclusion defensible. Because coverage flows directly from net operating income, and net operating income flows from the expense structure, a study that has rationalized its expenses can stand behind its debt-service coverage, while one that has understated them is reporting a coverage ratio that will not survive contact with reality. The discipline extends into sensitivity analysis, where a rigorous study stresses the expense assumptions the lender most worries about, utility inflation, an insurance spike, wage increases, a property-tax reassessment, and shows how coverage holds under each. The purpose of that stress-testing is not to flatter the deal but to demonstrate that the downside is survivable, which is the assurance a lender most needs on a leveraged credit.

    What underwriters look for

    An experienced underwriter reads the expense side for a specific set of red flags, and a rationalized study is built to pass each. The missing management fee, the seller's old property taxes, the absent replacement reserve, the stale insurance assumption, the understated labor line, the total expense ratio sitting implausibly below the industry norm, and the round-number plug that betrays a figure never actually built, are the recurring tells of an optimistic pro forma. A study that includes the market management fee, reassesses the taxes, funds the reserve, prices insurance at current cost, staffs at market wages, and reconciles its total to the benchmark for the asset class survives that scrutiny, because it has already asked and answered the questions the underwriter will ask.

    The bottom line

    The expense side of a feasibility study is where rigor is quietly tested and where studies most often quietly fail. Understated expenses inflate net operating income and coverage without the visible reach of an aggressive revenue line, and the omissions that cause it, the uncosted owner, the un-reassessed taxes, the unfunded reserve, the stale insurance, are invisible unless the analyst knows to build each line from the bottom up and reconcile it to a named benchmark. That discipline, expense rationalization, is what allows a study to stand behind its coverage conclusion under conservative review, and it is what distinguishes an analysis a lender can underwrite from a projection a lender must reject. On the expense side, credibility is not asserted; it is constructed, line by line, against the evidence.

    Frequently asked questions

    Why do feasibility studies get rejected for expense problems rather than revenue?

    Revenue draws instinctive scrutiny, so an aggressive revenue line is usually caught, while expense understatement is subtler and more common because a plausible-looking set of line items rarely announces what it has left out. Omissions such as a missing management fee, an unfunded replacement reserve, or property taxes still at the seller's basis are invisible unless the reviewer knows to look for them, and each inflates net operating income and therefore coverage just as surely as overstated revenue does.

    What is operating expense rationalization?

    It is the practice of justifying every expense line independently, from the bottom up, against industry data and market cost rather than deriving it as a percentage plug or carrying it over from the borrower's projection. The method has two movements: each line is built from the operation's actual requirements and benchmarked against comparable operations, and the assembled total is reconciled against the industry's benchmark ratios as a cross-check, so a figure that falls outside the norm is caught and explained rather than accepted.

    Why does a feasibility study include a management fee for an owner-operated business?

    Because the lender models the business as it would operate under professional management rather than assuming the owner's uncompensated effort. A rationalized study includes a market-rate management fee, commonly 3 to 6 percent of revenue depending on the asset class, even when the business is owner-operated, because an owner who works without a market salary understates the true cost of running the business. Omitting the management fee is among the most frequent and most consequential expense understatements.

    How should property taxes be modeled in a feasibility study after an acquisition?

    Property taxes should be estimated from the new assessed value and the local millage, reflecting the reassessment that an acquisition or new construction triggers, not carried at the seller's old tax basis. Using the seller's basis is a classic understatement, because a transaction commonly resets the assessment, sometimes substantially, and a study that ignores the reassessment understates the tax line and overstates the coverage that flows from it.

    What is a replacement reserve and why do lenders expect it?

    A replacement reserve is a funded allowance for capital items that wear out, the hotel FF&E reserve commonly modeled near 4 percent of revenue, the equipment replacement for a car wash or laundromat, the roof and HVAC for any building. Lenders expect it because capital assets genuinely deteriorate, and a projection that omits the reserve flatters near-term coverage at the expense of realism. It is not a discretionary line but a recognition that the business must fund its own physical renewal.

    How does understating expenses affect the debt-service coverage ratio?

    Directly and disproportionately. Coverage is net operating income divided by debt service, and net operating income is revenue less expenses, so an understated expense ratio flows straight into an overstated coverage figure. A study that models expenses several points below their true level does not overstate coverage by that same small margin; it overstates it by the full margin those points represent, which on a thin-coverage deal can be the difference between clearing the lender's floor and failing it.

    What expense benchmarks do feasibility analysts use?

    Rationalization depends on credible, named sources, including the IREM Income and Expense analyses, the RMA Annual Statement Studies, STR and CBRE trend data for hotels, NIC for senior housing, the Self Storage Association, the Coin Laundry Association, and franchise disclosure Item 19 for franchised businesses. Against these, representative operating expense ratios and net operating income margins by asset class serve as the reconciliation anchors, drawn from current editions for the specific market and asset in question.

    What expense red flags do SBA underwriters look for?

    Underwriters read the expense side for a recognizable set of tells: the missing management fee, the seller's old property taxes, the absent replacement reserve, the stale insurance assumption, the understated labor line, a total expense ratio implausibly below the industry norm, and round-number plugs that betray figures never actually built. A rationalized study that includes the management fee, reassesses the taxes, funds the reserve, prices insurance at current cost, and reconciles to the benchmark survives that scrutiny.


    Underwriting a project that depends on a defensible pro forma? Union prepares independent, lender-grade feasibility studies with expense structures rationalized line by line against named industry benchmarks, so the coverage conclusion holds under conservative review. Request a feasibility study to see what a defensible, evidence-led analysis looks like for your project.

    Book a ConsultationRequest a Proposal

    Related reading

    Working a live file? Our SBA feasibility study consultants guide sets out scope, timing and what lenders and CDCs expect, the engagement record shows completed studies by asset class, and the full article index lists everything published here.

    Reference material: glossary of SBA and feasibility terms, feasibility study FAQ, document checklist, educational center, calculator suite and the full resources library.

    Engage an SBA feasibility study consultant

    We are an independent SBA feasibility study company. Our SBA feasibility study consultants prepare lender ready studies under SOP 50 10 8 standards. See feasibility study cost and pricing, then request a fixed fee quote. Every study is benchmarked against our flagship SBA Feasibility Risk Meter research on 1,036,077 SBA loans.

    Also useful: completed engagement record, our methodology, original SBA loan research and the firm and analyst profile.